Respiratory hazards can cause serious long-term health damage before any symptom appears. They do not have to cause any coughing or other discomfort before damaging the lungs of workers exposed to them. Therefore, in many cases, respirators are the only effective way to protect against respiratory hazards. However, their use can be delayed for many years, which makes them easy to disregard in safety work and very costly when errors occur.
However, as one program developer commented, once a control has been chosen there are really three further things to be concerned with, the justification of that control, verification that the chosen control is still suitable for the wearer, and finally the update of evidence as both the workforce and the work it does change.
What the exposure data actually tells you
You select respirators based on a number, not on the contents of a catalogue. The required protection factor for a given application must be derived from the estimated or measured concentration of airborne contaminants present in the workplace against the relevant WES.
Estimation of concentrations is often based on published information that describes the emission from similar tasks and processes. While such an estimation must include a number of assumptions which must be documented and carefully checked for conservatism, it can often be a suitable alternative to measurements of very low concentrations. The selection of a P2 disposable mask because it is available from the local hardware store is not acceptable.
Oxygen deficiency and IDLH conditions change the calculation entirely
Air-purifying respirators are filters which can remove contaminants from the atmosphere. The respirator does not add any oxygen to the atmosphere and so cannot be used in an Immediate Danger to Life or Health situation. Supplied Air Respirators and Self-Contained Breathing Apparatus are the only types of respirators suitable for confined space entry, for firefighting and for work where the atmosphere is unknown.
Matching the respirator class to the hazard and the task
Many factors must be taken into account when selecting suitable respiratory protective equipment. For example, work rate and duration, and the workers’ means of communication with each other. Equipment must also take into account any heat stress that the worker may experience whilst wearing it. Additionally, where work is also exposing the worker to gases and/or vapours, in addition to dust, consideration must be taken for the correct type of mask.
| Respirator type | Typical required minimum protection factor | Best suited to | Key limitation |
| Disposable filtering facepiece (P2) | 10 | Short-duration dusty tasks, nuisance particulate | No gas or vapour protection, fit varies between batches |
| Half-face reusable with cartridges | 10 | Routine solvent, paint and abrasive work | No eye protection, cartridge change-out must be scheduled |
| Full-face reusable | 50 | Higher concentrations, irritant vapours | Heavier, interferes with prescription eyewear |
| Powered air-purifying (PAPR) | 50 to 100 | Long shifts, hot conditions, beards in some designs | Battery management, higher capital and maintenance cost |
| Supplied air line | 50 to 1000+ | Confined space, spray booths, high concentrations | Requires certified breathing air quality and escape provision |
Fit is the variable that determines real-world performance
Assigned Protection Factors (APFs) assume a proper seal of the mask to the wearer’s face. However, many factors can alter the seal, including a wide variety of face shapes, beards, scar tissue, and even weight gain. A few percent leakage can reduce the APF by as much as half. These are the kinds of errors that “paper” respiratory programs incur in silence.
The gap is best closed by arranging formal mask fit testing for every worker issued a tight-fitting respirator. Quantitative fit testing uses a respirator to measure the difference in concentration of test particles before the mask is placed over the face of the test subject and after the mask has been fitted to the face of the test subject, during a series of realistic activities. A measure of the fit of the mask to the face of the test subject is then obtained from the results of the testing, and this is expressed as a fit factor. Qualitative fit testing involves giving the test subject a test agent that is either perceived positively or negatively by the nose and throat and asking for their perception of the test agent.
When retesting is warranted
- At induction, before the worker enters any area requiring respiratory protection
- Annually, as a baseline frequency for all tight-fitting respirators
- After any change in make, model or size of facepiece
- Following significant weight change, facial surgery or dental alteration
- When a worker reports discomfort, fogging or repeated seal failure during use
Fit check is not fit test
These simple procedures can be performed by users every time they don a respirator to check for a positive and negative pressure seal. They can verify that the respirator is properly seated on the user’s face every time but these results are not recorded or measured.
Building the program so it survives an audit
The chain of hazard to control to verification needs to be documented and a single system adopted rather than control being left on sites.
- Written exposure assessments with sampling dates and methods
- Documented selection rationale linking each task to a respirator class
- Fit test records showing method, fit factor, make, model and size
- Training records covering donning, doffing, cleaning and cartridge change-out schedules
- Health monitoring where the substance triggers a statutory requirement
- Scheduled review following process change, incident or new sampling data
Clean-shaven policies need practical alternatives
Requiring users to shave against religious beliefs or medical conditions on the skin creates huge amounts of frustration and enforcement will generally reduce to zero very quickly. PAPR hoods loose fitting over the head are an acceptable solution to this conflict and cost less than the industrial relations problem they prevent.
Where the effort pays back
Claims for respiratory disease can take years to manifest and can cost a fortune to treat with strong probabilities of unsuccessful defence of lack of exposure evidence. Establishing and running a Respiratory Protection Program effectively will change an open-ended liability into an asset that is managed with confidence and protects the workforce in a very practical way.